Bechara et al
- how this plays out in their
lives - like, do they frequently find themselves doing things that they
know are wrong?
á isn't
it also possible that "normal" participants are simply choosing the
option that causes less arousal?
- the best way to avoid
arousal is to stay home, yet casinos are incredibly popular?
- arousal that most people
experience when making risky choices is reinforcement only for some people
- IGT can predict recidivism
in substance abuse
- combine the neuroscientific
techniques discussed in the Damasio article with racism-related studies
like DovidioÕs
- Would it be the same thing
that differentiated a)the normal subjects and b)the patients who did and
did not reach the conceptual period.
- how the participants with
neurological damage [to the VPFC] would do with fear conditioning and
extinction?
- whether ventromedial PFC
also contributes to the learned helplessness phenomenon
- decision making can be
altered by things outside our conscious control--heuristics,
naturally-occurring chemicals, lesions
- when do we develop this
unconscious ability? Could this ability be potentially reinforced and when
do all the confounding heuristics start to come into play?
- Milgram's study with a
control group as well as patients with ventromedial prefrontal cortex
lesions.
- when asked why he continued
to gamble, the man responded that it was only because the money wasn't
really his own—
Tversky-
Kahneman
- "intuition" (or
"implicit knowledge"? "preconscious knowledge"?) can
occur (and be accurate!) prior to explicit decision making
- biases in judgments made by
all of us, to the very different way these biases in judgments are
discussed in connection to psychopathology
- Awareness of these types of
heuristics and biasesÉis important, not only for psychologists but for
everyone.
- So, we use heuristics and
make mistakes in our decisions making process... so? There is also plenty
of (very important data) on why heuristics and stereotypical thinking are
so beneficial to our thinking. So- what should I conclude? Clearly I can't
do away with using heuristics, so why point out the problems with using
them? What am I supposed to do with this information?
- if nothing else, having
this information may have gotten me a job or two.
- we were learning exactly
how silly humans are, but I think it's bigger than just a few little
biases. Consequences: economic and interpersonal, biases and stereotypes
- "Gut Instinct's
Surprising Role in Math." –see Wynn article later on
- even if we cannot alter our
use of heuristics in many cases, simply being aware of that tendency can
affect our behavior.
- Some of the heuristics and
biases described in this seminal paper are not universal.
- How heuristics and biases
might affect people's understandings and interpretations of Obama and
Mccain's debate last night. – yes, how?
- why regression to the mean
happens
- I agree that these
cognitive short cuts have evolutionary merits, but I also think that in
todays day and age, when we have so much access to information and facts,
that these cognitive limitations cannot entirely absolve people from the
decision they make in terms of how they judge people.
- the modern problem is less
an issue of a lack of information than a lack of attention to the right
information.
- at least gives struggling
stats students some validation for their difficulties
Murphy et
al
- impulsivity vs.
risk-seeking
- potential confounds (i.e.
medication type, severity of illness)
- high comorbidity rates
between disorders such as bipolar and substance abuse
- this experiment done with
adolescents
- I would have expected that
manic pts would have had lower deliberation, since mania is associated
with impulsivity.
- if the participants'
decision-making skills had improved since they began taking medication
- possible that the
participants were not in a manic episode
- I think there is a
difference in terms of how depressed versus manic patients interpret
information
- Whether verbal
clarification would have altered any of their decision making processes?
- only the manic patients
were impaired in the quality of their decisions - supports the clinical
accounts
- It would be interesting to see
this done in bipolar individuals.